Cat Mom Life

Do People With Higher IQs Prefer Cats or Dogs? What Science Says

A woman sitting on a plaid blanket in a lush grassy field with her tabby cat and golden retriever dog.

Have you ever heard someone say that cat lovers are smarter than dog lovers? If you’re a cat person, you might secretly enjoy hearing that. And if you’re a dog person, you might already be preparing to defend your furry best friend!

The idea that people with higher IQs prefer cats has been circulating for years, and surprisingly, it isn’t entirely made up. Some psychological research has found differences between people who identify as cat people and those who consider themselves dog people, including differences in certain measures of intelligence.

But does that mean intelligent people naturally prefer cats? Are cat lovers really smarter, or is there more to the story?

If you’re someone who considers a cat part of the family, you might also enjoy exploring what it really means to be a cat mom.

Let’s look at what the research actually tells us.

Do People With Higher IQs Prefer Cats or Dogs?

The short answer is: There is some research suggesting that cat people score higher on certain measures of intelligence, but there is not enough evidence to conclude that people with higher IQs generally prefer cats.

One study published in 2017 found that participants who identified as cat people scored higher on a brief measure of general intelligence than those who identified as dog people.

However, that finding needs some context. The study did not establish that cat lovers have higher IQs overall, nor did it prove that intelligence determines someone’s choice of pet.

So, where did the idea come from?

The Study That Started the Cat People Are Smarter Debate

In 2017, researchers Andrea D. Guastello, Denise D. Guastello, and Stephen J. Guastello published a study titled Personality Differences between Dog People and Cat People.

The researchers examined 418 university students who completed a personality questionnaire and a survey about their pet preferences.

The participants were divided into two groups:

  • 352 identified as dog people.
  • 66 identified as cat people.

The questionnaire, known as the Sixteen Personality Factors Questionnaire (16PF), measured different personality characteristics and included a brief measure of general intelligence.

Interestingly, the researchers found that cat people scored higher in three areas:

  • General intelligence: They scored higher on the questionnaire’s brief intelligence measure.
  • Abstractedness: They tended to score higher on a trait associated with imagination and abstract thinking.
  • Self-reliance: They tended to score higher on independence and relying on their own judgment.

Dog people, on the other hand, scored higher in warmth, liveliness, rule consciousness, and social boldness.

These findings attracted attention because they offered a possible explanation for why people might be drawn to different companion animals.

However, there is an important distinction: the study measured a brief intelligence component within a personality questionnaire. It was not a comprehensive IQ assessment, and its participants were university students rather than a representative sample of the general population.

In other words, the findings are interesting, but they don’t prove that cat lovers are inherently more intelligent.

What Makes Cat People and Dog People Different?

Intelligence isn’t the only characteristic researchers have explored. Studies have also examined personality differences between people who prefer cats and those who prefer dogs.

A well-known 2010 study by psychologists Samuel Gosling, Carson Sandy, and Jeff Potter examined 4,565 participants who identified themselves as cat people, dog people, both, or neither.

The researchers found that dog people tended to score higher in:

  • Extraversion
  • Agreeableness
  • Conscientiousness

Cat people, meanwhile, tended to score higher in openness to experience.

These findings suggest that pet preferences may be associated with certain personality characteristics.

But why might someone feel more connected to one species than another?

1. Cat Lovers May Appreciate Independence

Cats are often admired for their independent nature.

They can enjoy spending time with their humans while still maintaining their own routines and personal space. Some cats love cuddles, while others prefer sitting nearby and observing everything happening around them.

For people who appreciate quiet environments, personal space, and a more independent companion, this relationship can be particularly appealing.

Of course, cats are individuals. Some are incredibly social and affectionate, while others are more reserved.

2. Dog Lovers May Enjoy Social Interaction

Dogs often require more structured daily interaction, including walks, training, playtime, and outdoor activities.

For people who enjoy being active and meeting others, these routines can be a wonderful part of everyday life.

Walking a dog can also create opportunities to meet other dog owners and socialize with people in the neighborhood.

This doesn’t mean all dog lovers are extroverts or that cat lovers dislike socializing. It simply illustrates how different lifestyles may influence pet preferences.

3. Lifestyle Can Influence Pet Preferences

Sometimes, choosing between a cat and a dog has very little to do with personality or intelligence.

A person’s living environment, daily schedule, family situation, and previous experiences with animals can all influence which pet suits them best.

For example, someone who works long hours or lives in a small apartment may find that a cat fits their circumstances better.

Someone who enjoys outdoor activities and has the time to provide regular exercise may prefer a dog.

Our preferences are shaped by many factors, not just personality.

Does Loving Cats Mean You’re More Intelligent?

Not necessarily!

Although the 2017 research found higher scores on a brief intelligence measure among cat people, it would be misleading to turn that result into a general rule.

There are several reasons to be cautious:

The sample was limited. All 418 participants were university students, so the findings cannot automatically be applied to everyone.

The groups were uneven. There were 352 dog people compared with only 66 cat people. This difference makes it important to interpret the results carefully.

Intelligence is complex. A brief measure within a personality questionnaire cannot capture every aspect of human intelligence.

Correlation doesn’t establish causation. The researchers identified an association between pet preference and certain characteristics. They did not demonstrate that intelligence causes someone to prefer cats.

And most importantly, no study has established that owning or loving a cat makes someone smarter.

You can be an intelligent cat lover, an intelligent dog lover, or someone who adores both. Your choice of companion doesn’t determine your intellectual abilities.

Can You Be Both a Cat Person and a Dog Person?

Absolutely!

Not everyone feels the need to choose sides in the great cat-versus-dog debate.

Some people enjoy the playful companionship of dogs and the quieter affection of cats. Others grew up with dogs but developed a special connection with cats later in life.

A 2024 exploratory study published in Animals examined how people’s preferences for cats and dogs develop and how those preferences relate to their interactions with their pets.

The researchers found that childhood exposure to animals was associated with later preferences. Some participants who preferred cats as adults had previously identified as dog people.

This is a useful reminder that our relationships with animals can change over time.

You don’t have to be exclusively a cat person or a dog person to appreciate what each animal brings into your life.

So, Who Wins: Cat People or Dog People?

If you’re hoping for a scientific verdict declaring cat lovers the intellectual winners, the evidence isn’t quite there!

One study did find that cat people scored higher on a brief measure of general intelligence, but that doesn’t establish that people with higher IQs prefer cats.

What research does suggest is that cat and dog preferences can be associated with different personality characteristics and life experiences.

And honestly, perhaps that’s what makes the relationship between humans and animals so interesting.

Some people love the enthusiastic greeting of a dog waiting at the door. Others love the quiet moment when a cat chooses to curl up beside them.

Neither preference is better.

At PurrKiss, we’re certainly happy to celebrate the special bond between cats and their humans. But we’ll leave the intelligence competition to the researchers!

After all, you don’t need a high IQ to know that a purring cat on your lap can make an ordinary day feel wonderful.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are cat lovers smarter than dog lovers?

A 2017 study involving 418 university students found that participants who identified as cat people scored higher on a brief measure of general intelligence. However, this does not prove that cat lovers are generally smarter than dog lovers.

Do intelligent people prefer cats?

There is currently insufficient scientific evidence to establish that people with higher IQs are more likely to prefer cats. Pet preferences are influenced by several factors, including personality, lifestyle, and previous experiences with animals.

What personality traits are associated with cat lovers?

Some studies have associated cat preference with higher openness to experience, independence, and abstractedness. However, these are group-level findings and do not describe every cat lover.

Are dog lovers more outgoing than cat lovers?

A 2010 study found that people identifying as dog people scored higher in extraversion than those identifying as cat people. This suggests an association, not a rule that applies to every individual.

Does owning a cat improve intelligence?

There is no convincing scientific evidence that owning a cat increases a person’s IQ. However, interacting with pets can be a meaningful and enjoyable part of everyday life.

Can someone be both a cat person and a dog person?

Of course! Many people love both species. Pet preferences are not fixed personality categories, and people’s preferences can change with experience.